2016
First Annual Dragon (Con) Award nomination: Best Graphic Novel – Virgil
First Annual Virginia Library Association Graphic Novel Diversity Award: Honorary Book: Adult – Virgil
2014
Eisner Award nomination: Best Anthology – Outlaw Territory Vol. 3
Harvey Award nomination: Best Anthology – Outlaw Territory Vol. 3
2011
Harvey Award winner: Best Anthology – POPGUN Vol. 4
Harvey Award nomination: Best Online Comic Work – The Guns of Shadow Valley
Ghastly Award nomination: Best Archival Collection – AWAKENING Omnibus (Archaia)
Ghastly Award nomination: Best Letterer
2010
Eisner Award winner: Best Anthology – POPGUN Vol. 3
Eisner Award nomination: Best Digital Comic – The Guns of Shadow Valley
Harvey Award nomination: Best Letterer
Harvey Award nomination: Best Anthology – POPGUN Vol. 3
Diamond Gem Award nomination: Best Anthology – POPGUN Vol. 3
2009
Harvey Award nomination: Best Anthology – POPGUN Vol. 2
2008
Harvey Award winner: Best Anthology – POPGUN Vol. 1
Eagle Award nomination: Favourite Letterer